15 Best Pizza Places in Green Bay: The Ultimate Guide

Discover the top 15 best pizza places in Green Bay, offering a range of mouthwatering options. Explore Green Bay’s pizza scene today!

When it comes to pizza in Green Bay, Wisconsin, the city’s vibrant culinary scene is impossible to ignore. Green Bay offers a diverse range of pizzerias, from classic thin crust to mouthwatering deep-dish options, ensuring there’s something for every pizza lover. In this comprehensive guide, we have carefully selected and curated a list of the 15 best pizza places in Green Bay. Whether you’re a local resident or a visitor exploring the city, these establishments promise an unforgettable dining experience filled with delicious flavors and delightful ambiance. Get ready to embark on a pizza adventure in Green Bay like no other!

The Best Pizza Places in Green Bay

1. The Black Sheep

Situated in the heart of downtown Green Bay, The Black Sheep combines unique flavors with high-quality ingredients. Their wood-fired oven creates crispy thin-crust masterpieces, and their inventive toppings will surprise and delight your taste buds.

2. Polito’s Pizza

A local favorite for over 50 years, Polito’s Pizza serves up traditional New York-style pizza. Their hand-tossed crust, flavorful sauce, and generous toppings make it a top choice for pizza enthusiasts.

3. Glass Nickel Pizza Co.

Known for their creative and diverse menu, Glass Nickel Pizza Co. offers a plethora of specialty pizzas. From classic combinations to unique concoctions like their “Fetalicious” pizza, this place is sure to satisfy any pizza lover.

4. Maria’s Pizza

Nestled in a cozy neighborhood, Maria’s Pizza is famous for its Sicilian-style pies. Baked in a pan with a thick, doughy crust and loaded with toppings, these pizzas are a hearty and delicious treat.

5. Ned Kelly’s

This Irish pub and pizzeria serves up exceptional thin-crust pizzas. Their homemade dough, flavorful sauce, and fresh toppings create a delightful and authentic dining experience.

6. Rustique Pizzeria + Lounge

Offering a trendy atmosphere and a menu inspired by Italian traditions, Rustique Pizzeria + Lounge crafts artisanal Neapolitan-style pizzas. The light, chewy crust and the combination of imported and local ingredients set them apart.

7. Happy Joe’s Pizza & Ice Cream

A family-friendly favorite, Happy Joe’s Pizza & Ice Cream specializes in a unique taco pizza that has become a Green Bay institution. Their blend of Mexican and Italian flavors is truly something to savor.

8. Sammy’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant

With a history dating back to 1954, Sammy’s Pizza & Italian Restaurant is an iconic establishment in Green Bay. Their thin-crust pizzas are prepared with a homemade sauce and a perfect balance of toppings, ensuring a classic and satisfying pizza experience.

9. Glass Nickel Pizza Co. East Side

A sister location of the original Glass Nickel, this establishment offers the same quality and creativity as its sibling. Their extensive menu, featuring gluten-free and vegan options, caters to all dietary preferences.

10. Luigis’ Pizza Palace

Established in 1993, Luigis’ Pizza Palace serves authentic Italian cuisine with a focus on pizza. Their homemade dough and family recipes create an inviting and delicious dining experience.

11. Three Three Five

This upscale dining spot is renowned for its artistic presentations and unique flavor combinations. While their menu changes regularly, their wood-fired pizzas never disappoint and are a must-try for pizza connoisseurs.

12. Chives Restaurant

Although known for its contemporary American cuisine, Chives Restaurant excels at creating gourmet pizzas. Their dedication to using local and seasonal ingredients ensures that every bite is bursting with flavor.

Green Bay’s pizza scene is a treasure trove of culinary delights, with each establishment offering its unique twist on this beloved dish.

13. Villa Italian Kitchen

Located in the Bay Park Square Mall, Villa Italian Kitchen offers a convenient and delicious pizza experience. Their New York-style slices are perfect for a quick bite while shopping or catching a movie.

14. Glass Nickel Pizza Co. West Side

With a third location in Green Bay, Glass Nickel Pizza Co. continues to impress with its wide variety of specialty pizzas. Their commitment to quality and flavor has earned them a place on this list.

15. Sgambati’s New York Pizza

Last but not least, Sgambati’s New York Pizza is a must-visit for those seeking an authentic taste of the Big Apple. With hand-tossed crusts and generous portions, their New York-style pizzas are a delight.

Green Bay’s pizza scene is a treasure trove of culinary delights, with each establishment offering its unique twist on this beloved dish. Whether you prefer thin crust, deep-dish, or artisanal pies, the 15 pizza places listed above are guaranteed to satisfy your cravings. From traditional favorites to innovative creations, these pizzerias are the best Green Bay has to offer. So, gather your friends and family, embark on a pizza adventure, and discover the flavors that make Green Bay a pizza lover’s paradise.